Smriti Irani Vs Doctor’s Family Over Weekend Accident On Highway

New Delhi: Two days after Smriti Irani tweeted about helping the injured after a highway pile-up in which her car was also caught, the young daughter of a doctor who was killed has come out with a different story.

Ramesh Nagar, an Agra-based doctor, was killed after a car in the minister’s convoy hit him on the Noida Expressway, his family has alleged in an FIR or police complaint.


Dr Nagar daughter Sandili alleges that he died on the road after getting no medical help. Sandili and her younger cousin also on the bike and were going to a wedding with him.

Sandili Nagar alleges that she pleaded for help but “Smriti Irani ignored us”. She and her cousin allegedly waited for several hours for first aid.

“The HRD minister’s car hit our bike, which was at slow speed. Our bike fell. I asked for help but they said no. They said you can get help later. If she wanted, she could have helped us. If she had helped us, my father would have been there with us,” said Sandili.

She claimed that Ms Irani walked out of her car, which was damaged, got into another car and drove off.

Ms Irani was on her way to Delhi after attending a BJP youth convention in Mathura when the accident allegedly took place.

“Unfortunately, the police vehicle before mine and my car also crashed,” tweeted the minister.


  1. If the story line above is true, it’s every unfortunate, Ms Irani hasn’t shown very basic human gesture of taking ar arranging to shift the victim to the nearest hospital…. Mera Bharat Mahan!

  2. The BJP is the party of the high caste and high class, who cares for the poor? Srmiti Irani, your actions from day one were anti-minorities; started with the tricky plan to take off the Christmas from the Indian calendar, then other actions.
    That action tormented everybody in the nation, especially the Christians. Wait and watch the karma effect!

  3. “The HRD minister’s car hit our bike, which was at slow speed. Our bike fell. I asked for help but they said no. They said you can get help later. If she wanted, she could have helped us. If she had helped us, my father would have been there with us,” said Sandili. – Report

    Oh well! Our ‘blunderful’, Yale ‘educated’ minister has ONCE again proven that she is fit ONLY for soaps.

    To walk away from such a disaster is a remarkable display of ‘tolerance’ indeed! Do I hear our know-all phoreen Rampai say ‘eye’? 🙂

    • Praveen: Now the BJP leaders are patting behind Mr. Modi and declaring that Modiji is a special God sent gift to India. Why did God take such an emergency action especially towards India ignoring the rest of the world? God loves India.

      In Quran, Musa who is Moses in the Bible has been elevated as the top ranking prophet in Quran. In Hinduism we don’t see any prophet or founder; but quite surprisingly, the BJP Ministers are acting like prophets of the Hindu religion. Thus, the God-sent Musa of India to deliver the Hebrews from the Egyptian bondage who has appointed Srmiti Irani as the Minister may say something very solid and affirmatively, why and how she did react to the begging appeal of the wounded people likewise? I am afraid that they would be charged with slow driving.

  4. “Sandili Nagar alleges that she pleaded for help but “Smriti Irani ignored us” – Report.

    I agree that our politicians are notorious with their ‘laal batti’ culture. However, I find it really hard to believe this story. Even the worst politicians are not that bad to ignore someone pleading for help after being hit by a car. There must be something more to this story. Or, this report is deliberately made to mislead readers into believing that Minister saw the cash, ignored the person pleading for help and simply moved on!!!

    @ AS Beef Mathew – Who taught you so much of brahmana dhwesha? Unbelievable!!

  5. Dear readers,

    These Bollywood turn politician thinking even real life is film set. They can only make audience sob watching there acting.
    But when it comes to real life humanitarian situation they turn actress.

    Only time they feel human is when their car is about knock ‘puppy'(Kuthe ka batcha) accidently falling under their motorcade as described by PM Modi interview to Reuters.

    In a latest incident following the footstep of ‘Pradhan sevak’,son of Andhra Pradesh Social Welfare Minister, Ravela Kishore Babu, and his driver for allegedly misbehaving with a woman.Ironically he is the son of TDP which is coalition partner of India.

    Andhra Pradesh Minister’s Son Allegedly Misbehaves With Woman In Hyderabad

    A case has been registered against Ravela Susheel, under Nirbhaya Act (IPC 354 D), for stalking the woman.

    Susheel has claimed in a post on social networking site Facebook that he had stopped car only to save a ‘PUP’ on the road and the woman started abusing him. “She misused the situation and misled the crowd because of which they lost control and started manhandling me,” he said in a statement.

    How can we expect humanity from Irani, a “part of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) from childhood” as her grandfather was an RSS swayamsevak and her mother a member of Jana Sangh.She broke the happy life Monica Irani to become Zubin Irani was doing pitty job then.

    The part is very generous arranging passport to Lalit Modi on Humanitarian aide.Where is that ‘Ramboism’ gone,when someone’s daughter is pleading for help?Is this the party asked to post ‘selfie with daughter’?

    HRD minister is responsible for the suicide of Dalit student Rohit Vermula.Now one more daughter of India became orphan.
    Thanks to party of difference and ‘Good governance’.
    Jai hind

Leave a Reply

Please enter your comment!

The opinions, views, and thoughts expressed by the readers and those providing comments are theirs alone and do not reflect the opinions of or any employee thereof. is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the readers. Responsibility for the content of comments belongs to the commenter alone.  

We request the readers to refrain from posting defamatory, inflammatory comments and not indulge in personal attacks. However, it is obligatory on the part of to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments to the concerned authorities upon their request.

Hence we request all our readers to help us to delete comments that do not follow these guidelines by informing us at Lets work together to keep the comments clean and worthful, thereby make a difference in the community.

Please enter your name here