Science must guide India, UK: Stoking vaccine nationalism will fail us all
One of the seven sins we should not commit as warned by Mahatma Gandhi is “science without humanity”. But are we conscious enough to ensure that the global fight against Covid is mindful of Gandhi ji’s message?
Right before Gandhi ji’s birth anniversary, the government of India announced its reciprocal policy for UK nationals arriving in India to undergo mandatory quarantine for 10 days after their arrival (regardless of their vaccination status). Earlier, UK had announced its travel policy that Indians, regardless of their vaccination status, will have to undergo the mandatory quarantine for 10 days after arriving in the UK.
The UK had announced an even more problematic policy but it had course-corrected when valid protests emerged against it not recognising vaccinated Indians because 90% of those fully vaccinated in India had received the vaccine (Oxford AstraZeneca) whose scientific research and development was done by UK-based agencies (though it was made in India by Serum Institute of India). Valid questions were raised will the UK also not recognise its own citizens who have received the same vaccine (but not made in India)? Thankfully, sanity prevailed and after few days and intense lobbying around the United Nations General Assembly, the UK government clarified that it does recognise the India-made Oxford AstraZeneca vaccine but its concern was towards the vaccine certification process in India.
The Indian government says that UK’s travel policy is discriminatory towards Indians. That is why the Indian government announced that from October 2021, all UK nationals travelling to India will also have to undergo a pre-departure Covid-19 RT-PCR test within 72 hours before travel, another RT-PCR test on arrival at the airport, and an RT-PCR test on the eighth day after arrival. They will also have to quarantine at home or at their destination address for 10 days.
Is nationalism trumping over science?
Not just UK and India but all countries worldwide need to be on the same page that the only possible way out of the pandemic is we stand united and progress together with oft-quoted chant by governments “no one is left behind”. Populations worldwide need to be fully vaccinated in a time-bound manner (United Nations health agency, the World Health Organization (WHO) target for all countries is to vaccinate 70% of populations globally by June 2022). Vaccinating populations globally will reduce the severity of the disease and bring down Covid deaths drastically (as has happened in countries where a large part of the population is fully vaccinated) as well as may give us hope to invoke herd immunity that may possibly show us the path out of the pandemic. However inequitable rollout of vaccines is so ugly with 80% of 6 billion vaccine doses delivered in rich nations so far. Hope this changes for more equity in vaccine rollout worldwide.
All countries also need to break the chain of infection transmission. People should wear proper masks, maintain physical distance, hygiene, and other measures to curtail the risk of infection spread, as much as possible.
Thailand’s mandatory quarantine policy for all foreign arrivals
Thailand government has had a strict mandatory quarantine policy for everyone who landed in the land of smiles regardless of which country the person came from. Two weeks quarantine among other measures (in a hotel facility) is a standard norm in Thailand. Thailand is also reporting an alarming number of new cases though but we have to compliment Thailand for reducing the risk of infection spread from those arriving via Thai airports.
So India and UK needs to decide: if mandatory quarantine for incoming passengers from a foreign land (regardless of vaccination status) is a good policy to reduce the risk of infection spread, then why only reciprocal to each other’s citizens, and why not for all incoming passengers on international flights landing in India or UK?
Science tells us that the specificity and sensitivity of Covid diagnostics is not 100% and vaccination currently reduces the risk of severity of Covid disease and reduces the risk of dying of Covid but evidence, whether vaccines prevent fully vaccinated people from getting infected from coronavirus (or spreading it to others), is still emerging.
So India and UK governments – if the intent is to reduce the risk of infection spread from those arriving from foreign nations, and if science tells us that mandatory quarantine is the right policy, then should it not be for all nationalities including Indians and English people arriving in their own nations from foreign lands?
Also, concerns of the UK government on Indian vaccine certification needs to be looked at without letting nationalistic jingo or ego cloud our judgment and decision making. Vaccine certification worldwide needs to be done in a way that it works like travel passports – which can be verified by authorities globally.
For example, recently there was news that fake vaccine certificates scam was exposed in states like Gujarat and Telangana. Or there were news reports of those who received the vaccine certificate without getting vaccinated. The Indian government has stepped up measures now and it is reported that the CoWin app has a more secure vaccine certification process for international travellers. We do hope this is in line with global standards.
Why are all 6 vaccines approved by India not being rolled out?
Also, we should not forget that currently six vaccines are approved in India but only three are being used. Among these three vaccines, only one of these is majorly used (Oxford AstraZeneca vaccine made by Serum Institute of India, and sold as Covishield, is given ). Covaxin (made by Bharat Biotech) is also rolled out along with Sputnik (Russian vaccine) but the number of people who have got Sputnik is very low though Covaxin uptake is relatively more than Sputnik but far less than Covishield.
Why are the other three vaccines not being rolled out in India despite being approved sometime back? Moderna (licensed to Cipla for marketing), Johnson & Johnson single-dose vaccine (licensed to Biological-E for domestic production) and ZyCovD of Zydus Cadila are yet to make a debut in the country. Alongside scaling up the supply side, it is equally important to expand India’s capacity manifold to export vaccines to those countries in dire need of vaccines.
In this moment of a prolonged global public health emergency, hope not just India and UK but all countries worldwide will let Gandhi ji’s wisdom of “science with humanity” guide the Covid response.
Bobby Ramakant – CNS (Citizen News Service)
(Bobby Ramakant is a World Health Organization Director General’s WNTD Awardee 2008, and part of CNS (Citizen News Service) and Asha Parivar teams. Follow him on Twitter @BobbyRamakant or read www.bit.ly/BobbyRamakant)