Sonia Gandhi’s memoir reestablishes Siddhartha Shankar Ray role in time preceding proclamation of Emergency
New Delhi: Congress Parliamentary Party Chairperson Sonia Gandhi’s memoir ‘Belonging: A Journey of Love’ mentions various aspects, including those related to the promulgation of the Emergency in 1975; but a brief mention of Siddhartha Shankar Ray accompanying Indira Gandhi when she met then President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed is historically significant.
For long time, Ray has widely been regarded as one of the key architects behind the legal and constitutional pathway trodden to proclaim Emergency. At the time, he was the Chief Minister of West Bengal (1972-77), and one of Indira Gandhi’s most trusted advisers, whom the author has described as a “legal luminary” present in closed-door meetings.
“One of Mrs Gandhi’s chief ministers, legal luminary Siddhartha Shankar Ray, and her law minister, H. R. Gokhale, were consulting with constitutional experts. They were unanimous in urging that the situation needed to be tackled firmly; the government had been too soft and permissive, and the situation had got out of hand,” wrote Sonia Gandhi, adding, “Sanjay (Gandhi) joined the confabulations,” whose role she has described in detail.
Several historical accounts, including memoirs by other political leaders, state that Ray suggested using Article 352 of the Constitution to declare a National Emergency on the ground of “internal disturbance”.
One narrative has even recounted that Indira Gandhi herself had once said she had not been fully aware of the constitutional provision until it was brought to her attention by Ray.
Incidentally, Ray had served as the Governor of Punjab between 1986 and 1989, where his tenure was marked by accusations of excesses. He has also been Union Minister for Education and Social Welfare (1971-72), Ambassador to the United States (1992-96), and was also sent as counsel to the Supreme Court of Pakistan.
Beyond discharging the duties of his political office, Ray, being a distinguished lawyer, is believed to have helped formulate legal actions, including the justification for imposing the Emergency after the Allahabad High Court verdict that invalidated Indira Gandhi’s 1971 election.
With political opposition intensifying and consolidating with Jayaprakash Narayan’s movement, an anti-Indira wave was gaining momentum, and Ray had reportedly argued that the government could invoke constitutional emergency powers to maintain order.
It was an inference that Sanjay Gandhi also reflected on many occasions, and whose name the author wrote had become synonymous with the Emergency, when he was just thirty years old, a man in a hurry.
While most narratives of the Emergency focus on Indira Gandhi, Sanjay Gandhi, or President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed – where the last is largely reported to have agreed to sign under pressure – Ray’s role is comparatively less discussed.
On the then President’s role, Sonia Gandhi’s book described him as “a lawyer by profession, (who) had signed the proclamation of a State of Emergency – willingly, and not, as later rumours had it, under coercion”. And as she mentioned, “As we later learned from my mother-in-law, she had met the president with S. S. Ray and briefed him in person in the afternoon of the twenty-fourth (June, 1975).”
The reference to Ray’s presence at critical meetings is a reminder that the Emergency was not conceived by an individual acting alone, rather highlighting the role of a small circle of advisers who provided legal, constitutional, and political counsel during the crisis.
Ray went on to become one of the most controversial figures associated with the Emergency. His critics have long argued that he provided the constitutional roadmap that enabled the suspension of civil liberties and the concentration of power in the Prime Minister’s Office.
His defenders, however, maintain that he acted within the constitutional framework available at the time and was responding to what was perceived as a grave political crisis.
However, his historical importance lies in being widely regarded as the principal legal adviser, along with other Indira Gandhi loyalists, who helped conceptualise and justify the Emergency.
Now, Sonia Gandhi’s memoir has reestablished Ray’s place alongside Indira Gandhi and Sanjay during the crucial interactions preceding the proclamation.
It is, in fact, indirectly a reinforcement of the long-held view that he was not a peripheral figure but a central participant in the decision-making process.













